Lesson 9
Is It a Good Idea to Control Population
Growth in the World?
Text
What Overpopulation Feels Like
We moved slowly through the city in a taxi and entered
a crowded slum district. The temperature was well over 100°and the air
was thick with dust and smoke. The streets seemed alive with people.
People eating, people washing, people sleeping. People visiting each
other, arguing and screaming. People pushing their hands through the taxi
windows, begging. People relieving themselves.
People holding on
to the sides of buses. People leading animals. People, people, people,
people. As we drove slowly through the crowd, sounding the taxi' s horn,
the dust, heat, noise and cooking fires made it like a scene from Hell.
Would we ever get to our hotel? All three of us were, I admit, frightened.
Since that night, I've known what overpopulation feels like.
Statistics show that rapid population growth creates
problems for developing countries. So why don't people have fewer
children? Statistics from the developed countries suggest that it is only
when people' s living standards begin to rise that birth rates begin to
fa11. There are good reasons for this. Poor countries cannot afford social
services and old age pensions, and people's incomes are so low they have
nothing tospare for savings.
As a result,
people look to their children to provide them with security in their old
age. Having a large family can be a form of insurance. And even while they
are still quite young, children can do a lot of useful jobs on a small
farm . So poor people in a developing country will need to see clear signs
of much better conditions ahead before they will think of having smaller
families. But their conditions cannot be improved unless there is a
reduction in the rate at which population is increasing. This will depend
on a very much wider acceptance of family planning and this, in turn,will
mean basic changes in attitudes.
II. Read
Read the following passages. Underlirie the important
viewpoints while reading.
1. Childless - and Happy That Way
In a country where most people believe that a family is
not a family without children, some young couples, especially those with a
higher education, have chosen to keep their families to two members
-husband and wife.
"I can't afford to have a child," said Wang,
a promising research fellow with the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences.
Wang has been busy travelling abroad and has received
scholarship offers from a number of American universities that would
enable him to complete his PhD.
"He is a free bird who may leave the nest any day
and I've never cared much about a child," said Xiao Wei, Wang's wife,
business representative of a French company in Beijing.
Unlike the Wangs, Zhang and his wife have argued over
whether they should have a baby.
"When we were married six years ago, we decided to
adopt a waitand-see attitude on the issue. And after a couple of years, my
wife said she wanted to have a baby while I insisted we were just fine
without one. We have been arguing about the matter ever since, and now
that we are over 30, I think we' re likely to end up in accordance with my
wishes," said Zhang.
"There are many marriages that should have long
been broken. People just hold on because a divorce would hurt the children
most and the parents hate to face that prospect. So the couple sticks
together and winds up torturing each other.
"A real happy family is a family that, without
children, is still a happy family, ?said Zhang.
Ma Jiang, who has opened a trading company and was
instantly nicknamed Money Bags by his friends, said he would hate to be
bothered with a child.
"To me, being without a child, I am less bound by
household chores and can concentrate on my business. My lovely wife is all
I need, no third person," he said.
Ma' s wife, Xiao Lu, working for a government unit,
could have quit her job and become dependent on her "rich"
husband. But she decided against it.
"I can' t imagine what I would be like if I stayed
at home, doing household chores and breast-feeding a child. I' d rather
keep my independence at all costs," she said.
"Whatever people say, I believe that to have a
child means a lot of sacrifice. We're just not ready for that, fun or
misery," Ma's wife said. Hou Mingkun and his wife Luo Qian said theyi
weren't against having a child, boy or girl, if only the baby was
physically well developed. "One takes a risk when having a baby. I've
heard too many stories about children born with physical defects.
Since-t-here's no guarantee that the same won't happen to my baby, I think
I'd better not get myself
involved. People say `no pain, no gain,' but for me it's no gain, no
pain," Luo said.
The couple were classmates in high school and went to
the same university in Shanghai. Now, they are working for a computer
company in Beijing.
Those who choose not to have children have to overcome
some unexpected difficulties in defending their stance.
Influenced by the traditional view that one's worst sin
is having no descendants, most people still accept that a wife is not a
good wife if she doesn't have a child.
Though few Chinese believe in an after-life, they do
care a lot about growing old. For centuries, one of the purposes of having
children, sons especially, was to have someone take care of the parents
when they were old.
"Now, since both husband and wife are working,
they will have a pension when they retire. What happens now is that the
retired parents are supporting their adult children," Wang said.
"We're normal people, just like everyone else,
We,ve just chosen to live our own way which harms no one. I hope people
understand us," Wang said.
2. Three Babies Are Born Every Second
There are over 3, 800 million people in the world today, and the total is
increasing at the rate of .more than 76 million a year. United Nations
experts have calculated that it could be more than 7, 000 million by thc
end of this century.
The population is growing more quickly in some parts of
the world than others. The continents with the fastest growth rates are
Latin America (2.9 per cent) and Africa (2.6 per cent). Asia comes third
(2.1 per cent) but because its present population is so large it is there
that by far the greatest number of people will be added before the end of
the century.
3. Population Increase Has Wiped out the Material
Benefits People Have Achieved
| Matthew: |
Sarah, is there a need to control population only in countries |
|
like India, Africa, Brazil. . . those countries that
we.call the |
|
underdeveloped countries, or is there a case for limiting
population |
|
in Europe, for instance? |
| Sarah: |
The reason one would have to limit population is because |
|
you're running out of food and you're running out of |
|
resources. The people in Europe and America consume a far |
|
greater proportion of the world's resources and the world's food
than |
|
they do in India. So... um... population is directly related
to... |
|
um... consumption and your general impact on the environment. |
|
If as an individual your impact is far greater than anybody |
|
else's, um... then that is the factor that's important, rather
|
|
than how many people there are, or how many people can the |
|
world support. Now it's...obviously in that sense, it's possible |
|
to increase population if everybody's willing to um...use less |
|
material or eat less food, but it isn't if everybody's
continually |
|
wanting more and more and more, and this is... seems to he the |
|
trend at the moment. . . higher and higher consumption. . . with |
|
at the same time a greatly expanding population.And the problem |
|
in ... um... areas which are poor and which have expanding |
|
populations is that they try and develop and try and...er... |
|
get...er...more material |
|
benefits, but as soon as they do this, the population increase |
|
has.wiped out any benefits that they may have um... achieved.
|
| Matthew: |
But do you feel that this battle with a...a rapidly expandint |
|
population can be won? |
| Sarah: |
The most sensible thing is to realize that you can't go
on expanding |
|
human populations for ever and countries and individuals must
decide |
|
to have a policy which would limit population. |
4. An African Woman Says:
"...the Men Never Talk about It."
"To us, children are the most important thing in
life. When we marry, it is not above all to get a husband or wife, but to
have children. I had my thirteenth birth only a few months ago, and most
of my adult life I have had to care for a baby as well as do all my other
work in the house and in the fields. For a long time I have wanted no more
children, but I keep having them as long as I am with my husband.
A nurse comes to
visit our village regularly. She holds meetings for all the men and women
together, to explain about family planning. Now these are wellknown facts
to us, but still nobody in our village practises birth control. When. we
sit together with the nurse, everybody seems to agree that this is the
right thing to do when a family had grown big enough to give the parents
security in their old age, and there are enough hands to attend to all the
daily work. But when we go home, the men never talk about it My husband
and I attend every meeting, but in our home we have never talked about
birth control. I desperately want to stop having more children, but this
can only be done if my husband suggests it."
5. Free Birth Control Techniques Should
Be Available Everywhere
| Matthew: |
Peter, what sections of the population do you think free birth
control |
|
techniques should be available to? |
| Peter: |
They should be... available to all sections of the community er... |
|
things are getting to such a pitch that I personally think |
|
that...er...not only should birth control methods be available
to all |
|
sections of the community, but indeed should be compulsory.
There |
|
should be some kind of law which says that a family should not
have |
|
more than three children,.a complete maximum of three children,
if |
|
they have three children then they must be obliged by law,
almost, to |
|
use birth control, if not have er... various kinds of operation |
|
which... um... make conception impossible.
|
| Matthew: |
But surely this is very er... explosive in social terms? |
| Peter: |
It's very...it's a very totalitarian notion, but. the |
|
alternative...if we look around us in the world outside is
millions |
|
of people starving to death in places like India, and people |
|
suffering from malnutrition in. . . in other parts of the |
|
underdeveloped wor... world and indeed even in parts of the
dev...so |
|
called developed world. |
6. It's a World Probl'em
The rapid rise in world population is not creating
problems only for the developing countries. The whole world faces the
problem that raw materials are being used up at an increasing rate and
food production cannot keep up with the population increase. People in the
rich countries rnake the heaviest demands on the world's resources, its
food, fuel and land, and cause the most pollution. A baby born in the
United States will use in his lifetime 30 times more of the world's
resources than a baby born in India. Unless all the countries of the world
take united action to deal with the population explosion there will be
more and more people fighting for a share of less and less land, food and
fuel, and the future will bring poverty, misery and war to us all.
7. What Has Caused the Population Explosion?
The main reason is not so much a rise in birth rates as
a fall in death rates as a result of improvements in
public health services and medical care. Many more babies now survive
infancy, grow up and become parents, and many more adults are living into
old age so that populations are being added to at both ends. In Europe and
America the death rate began to fall during the Industrial Revolution. In
the developing countries of Africa, Asia and Latin America the fall in
death rate did not begin till much later and the birth rate has only
recently begun to fall.
8. "The Rich Get Richer and the Poor Get Babies..."
This sudden increase in tl~e population of the
developing countries has come at a difficult time. Even if their
population had not grown so fast they would have been facing a desperate
struggle to bring the standard of living of their people up to the point
at which there was enough food, housing, education, medical care and
employment for everyone to have a reasonable life. The poor countries are
having to run faster and faster in their economic activity in order to
stay in the same place, and the gap in wealth between rich and poor
countries grows wider every year
The most pressing problem created by the rapid increase
in population is a shortage of food. More mouths have to be fed every
year, and yet a high proportion of the existing population are not getting
enough of the right kind of food. Over the past two years the total amount
of food has decreased, and of course the total amount of food per person
has decreased even more sharply.
More and more of the babies born in developing
countries have been surviving infancy and now nearly half the people
living in those countries are under the age of 15.The adults have to work
harder than ever to provide for the needs of the children, who cannot
contribute to the economy until they are older. There is a shortage of
schools and teachers, and there are not enough hospitals, doctors and
nurses. Farming land is becoming scarce, so country people are moving to
the towns and cities in the hope of finding a better standard of living.
But the cities have not been able to provide housing, and the newcomers
live in crowded slums. Finally, there are too few jobs and unemployment
leads to further poverty.
|