Lesson 18
Should Women Be Treated the Same as Men?
Text
For Women, There Is a Long Way to Go
One-third of the people at work in Britain are women.
By 1975 they will, by law, be on a footing of equal pay with men. Their
prospects of reaching the top, however, are still far from equal.
A recently-published study called Women in Top Jobs
examines why this should be so. For the purposes of this study four
researchers, two men and two women, chose women in top management in two
business organizations and women in senior jobs in the BBC and the Civil
Service. In their findings they found that although there are conventional
and entrenched attitudes on both sides, there is a widespread awareness
that no society can afford not to utilise ability.
The studies confirm that there is no basic difference
be tween the standards and quality of work performance of women who have
reached top jobs and those of men in similar positions. Nevertheless,
there emerged some distinctive factors in the performance of women in top
jobs. Women were less interested in empire-building, in office politics,
in status symbols. They are likely to be less forceful and competitive
than men.
In the past, women tended to assume they would be
overtaken y men in the race to the top. However, today's young women are
far less philosophical about their status and are more aggressive in their
resentment at being treated as in some way inferior to men. On the other
hand, since lack of drive is one of the criticisms levelled against women,
perhaps this aggression is a positive advantage. Some young women, though,
find it very difficult to come to terms with the feeling hat
characteristics of authority which are acceptable in men are often not
acceptable in women.
A reason often advanced for women failing to reach the
top is their desire for balance between work and a life outside work.
Employers know this and tend, when a woman with young children applies for
promotion, to treat the fact that she has young children as an important
factor and, given the choice, are more likely to give promotion to a man
than to her.
What about women whose children are almost grown up?
Well, the writers of the study recommend a much more positive approach by
employers to women who want to return to their careers after their
children are off their hands.
II.Read
Read t6e following passages. Underline the important
viewpoints while reading.
1. What Women's Lib Is about
Women's Lib is short for the Women's Liberation Movement which got
its name in America some years ago. Its supporters demand their
freedom and equality with men.
In this dialogue Sheila believes in Women's Lib
while Harry has his doubts.
| Harry: |
I've never understood what this Women's Lib business is all
about.I can |
|
understand women in some countries struggling for their rights.
But it |
|
strikes me that here in Britain women havc already?got as much
freedom |
|
as they could possibly want. They've got the vote, they can go
to |
|
university, they can compete with men in the professions on
equal |
|
terms... |
| Sheila: |
Rubbishl You're fooling yourself. How many women members of
Parliament |
|
are there? About 30 out of 635. How many women company
directors? How |
|
many trade union leaders? How many judges?
|
| Harry: |
Not many, I agree. But why is that? Maybe their talents don't
lie in |
|
those directions. Perhaps they prefer to be housewives. |
| Sheila: |
Prefer to be housewives? You can't have any idea what it's like, |
|
when you've been married fifteen years and you've cleaned a
house every |
|
day; then your husband and kids come along and mess it all up
again. |
|
Can you imagine the monotony, the boredom, the frustration? |
| Harry: |
Oh yes, I can imagine it easily enough. But don't forget that a
lot of , |
|
men have equally boring jobs and less freedom to do them their
own |
|
way.But that's beside the point; the real point is that most
housewives |
|
in my experience, are" content to be housewives. Take my
wife Jane, for |
|
example. She's not bored or frustrated; she finds her life quite |
|
satisfying; she cleans, cooks, gardens...
|
| Sheila: |
Oh I'm aware of that.That's because over the centuries men have
trained |
|
and educated women to consider themselves inferior and to accept |
|
their position. It isn't just the men who are piejudiced against
the |
|
women. The women have become prejudiced against themselves.They |
|
believe they really are inferior. |
| Harry: |
You mean they've been conditioned to accept. an inferior
position. |
| Sheila: |
Exactly; they've been brainwashed. It's the job of the Women's
I.ib |
|
movement to open their eyes to the way they have been fooled and |
|
dominated and exploited all these years.
|
| Harry: |
So you want to take all these nice contented women and make them |
|
discontent and rebellious? |
| Sheila: |
Right. |
| Harry: |
I see. Well, I don't accept that the present system is the
result of |
|
conditioning or brain washing at all. It's the natural
biological |
|
function of a woman first to bring children into the world and
then to |
|
bring them up. That is how the animals do it. In the Stone Age,
when we |
|
were cavemen, the women stayed at home in the cave and the men,
being |
|
stronger and braver, went out to hunt.Now the men go out.and
earn money |
|
instead.The Women's Lib movement denies woman her natural
function.I'm |
|
not saying that wotnan's function is necessarily inferior; but I
am |
|
saying that it's.not the same.
|
| Sheila: |
So if something happened in the Stone Age it was
"natural" and so it |
|
would be perfectly right and proper and "natural" to
go and do it now. |
|
I suppose if a man thinks he wants a woman all he has to do is
go out |
|
and knock one on the head with his club and drag her home by the
hair. |
|
Or maybe swop her with his pal for a couple of tiger-skins? |
| Harry: |
Don't be silly. We've grown out of that sort of barbarity . |
| Sheila: |
I should jolly well hope so too. Anyway all this Stone Age stuff
is a |
|
myth made up by men. For all we know, Stone Age women were the
top |
|
dogs. |
| Harry: |
All right, let's drop the Stone Age. Let's come down to the
modern |
|
British family. I suppose you want to abolish it?
|
| Sheila: |
No, but I want to reorganize it; I believe that the housework
and the |
|
bringing up of the children should be shared equally. |
| Harry: |
How? The husband should wash up, presumably. |
| Sheila: |
Of course. |
| Harry: |
Well, I do that at my house; and I fill up the stove and mow the
lawn and |
|
dig the garden. |
| Sheila: |
Naturally. Those are men's jobs, anyway. |
| Harry: |
Oh! I didn't think you.believed in men's jobs' and women's jobs'
Anyway I |
|
do quite a lot of the shopping. |
| Sheila: |
Fancy that! |
| Harry: |
And in my time I've bathed a few babies. |
| Sheila: |
And changed nappies? |
| Harry: |
Both changed them and washed them. |
| Sheila: |
Well, all I can say is you must be pretty unusual. My husband's |
|
never touched a nappy in his life.
|
|
|
| Harry: |
I wouldn't say it was all that unusual. There are plenty of men
in England |
|
who do the same as I do. Maybe that's why our wives are so
satisfied. Now |
|
suppose we all did the same and there were enough nursery
schools and so |
|
on and all the women who wanted to work could do so, what would
you |
|
say to that? |
| Sheila: |
Well... |
| Harry: |
Now suppose I was to stay at home and do all the housework and
look after |
|
the children while my wife went out to work. What would you
think about |
|
that?
|
| Sheila: |
I'd approve of it. |
| Harry: |
And you'd be willing for her to do any job at all? |
| Sheila: |
Anything she was strong enough to do. |
| Harry: |
Good. Now some time last century a law was passed making it
illegal |
|
for women to work down the coalmines. You would like that law
abolished? |
| Sheila: |
Certainly. |
| Harry: |
I hope you won't want men to open doors for you and give up
their seats in |
|
the bus for you. |
| Sheila: |
Of course not, as long as I'm fit. |
| Harry: |
In fact, in return for equality you would give up all these
special |
|
allowances formerly made for the so-called weaker sex? |
| Sheila: |
If I'm going to be logical, yes. |
| Harry: |
Well, if women are going to be logical, that will be progress.
|
2. Women's Education Should Be Urged
Recently, a woman in a factory in Beijing was notified
that she was being laid off as part of the "optimization" work
force reductions in State enterprises. To escape humiliation at the hands
of her husband and mother-in-law, she tried to kill herself by swallowing
a bottle of sleeping pills.
After she was rescued, her mother took her to the
factory director, demanding that her daughter be re-employed. Otherwise,
she said, the director would be responsible for any accident tbat happened
to her daughter. In the end, the director agreed to grant the woman a
leave of absence at full pay plus bonus.
This is only one example of the problem for which
traditional theorists of women's studies and supporters of women's
liberation in China apparently have no ready solution. But some feminist
researchers recently urged that a new approach be adopted to help women
gain a fresh foothold in the struggle to improve their lives.
Traditionally, paid employment has been seen as the
only passage towards women's liberation. And the rate of women's
employment has been used as the major criterion in determining the level
of women's liberation .
However, after more than three decades, few Chinese
women feel liberated from the old burdens of family and children. They
feel they have simply been given more work.
"We now have to admit that women's employment
doesn't necessarily lead to their liberation, or more exactly, to the full
development of their personalities," said Ma Lizhen, an editor at
Chinese Women magazine.
"In China, " she said, "this road has
reached a dead end. "
For nearly 40 years, China has pursued policies that
encourage women to join the labour force.
But they have resulted in serious problems, such as low
efficiency in factories, strains on the State budget and a heavy load of
housework and child care in a family, Ma said.
This employment-oriented system has hurt the women's
fundamental interests as well, Ma said. Women were often put into jobs in
heavy manual labour with men more as a demonstration of equality than
because they were suited for the work. This left them more dependent on
favourable government policies and less competitive.
A survey conducted by Ma's magazine indicates that
about 70 per cent of the workers who will be squeezed out of the labour
force in the current optimization will be wornen. The survey also reveals
that more women than men prefer. Stzte employment, whieh is..more secure
and less competitive.
To protect women's interesta, some women organizations
l;ave urged the top leadership for more favourable policies for women. But
some feminists now disagree.
"We know that special government treatment alone
will not produce cornpo.tent women," Dai Qing, a noted writer and
journalist, said at a discussion. "On the contrary, it has made them
weaker and more dependent. What we should do now is to help women become
more able and self-confident. And the only way is through education."
The long-standing neglect of women's education,
especially in the countryside, has resulted in a large proportion of
female illiteracy, whose negative effect on the nation's devel.opment is
most strikingly seen in ihe country's barely controllable birth rate.
State statistics indicate that women make up about 70
per cent of China's 200 million illiterates. This situation cannot be
expected to improve soon as hundreds of thousands of girls in the
countryside are being forced by their parents to drop out of school at
early grades to help work at home or in the fields. Girls make up an
estimated 70 per cent of the dropouts in the countryside, according to
Chinese Women magazine.
"The women's movement should shift its focus from
employment to education," Dai urged.
"If women are taught self-supporting skills, they
will support themselves as opportunities arise even without special care.
"A good education will benefit a woman throughout
her life whether she is a career woman or a housewife," said Da.i,
who is working on a plan to set up what would be the only non-governmental
girls' school in the capital.
Another way to help women stand up to the current
challenge is for the media to give more positive coverage to housework and
good housewives or househusbands, Ma suggested.
China at present cannot afford to provide publicly all
the services traditionally performed within the family, such as cooking,
washing and care for children and the elderly. But many people dislike
doing housework because it is unpaid and unappreciated.
Ma proposed that society compensate in some way the people who work at
home.
"Thus fewer women workers would feel ashamed about
returuing home to do the housework, " she added.
These feminist researchers have also begun reflecting
on the sources of and philosophy behind the current setback in the China's
women's liberation movement. They noted that the
movement in China is still operating ithin the framework of male culture
because from the very beginning it was formulated and directed by men.
"They set the male sex as a model for women to follow.
So women remain the second sex," Ma said.
She argued that the time has come for Chinese women to
define their own roles in society. They should strive for a society in
which they can choose to work outside, or stay at home, in which they can
have more time to develop their own interests and improve community
conditions.
3. Two Top Career Women Say Family Also Matters
It was quite a surprise for Wang Yunfeng, 58-year-old
general manager of the Shenyang Department Store, to find herself at the
head of a list of Shenyang's top 10 modern women.
The list was the result of a competition organized by
the women's federation of Shenyang, capital of northeastern Liaoning
Province.
Zheng Baohua, director of the federation, said that
Wang won the most votes not just because she is the general manager of one
of the largest and most-progressive department stores in the country, but
also because of her compassion.
Wang was first in the city to promote lateral ties
between commercial establishments, and the total volume of profits her
department store turned over to the State over six years was 11 times more
than the total investment.
Wang's 83-year-old mother said that her husband died
very early. "It was Yunfeng who raised her three younger
brothers," she said, adding, "She never fails to bring me some
tasty pastry every time she comes home, no matter how busy she has been at
work."
A middle-school teacher who voted for Wang said,
"In my opinion, in addition to career success, modern women should
also be independent and charming, and have a sense of freedom. This, of
course, has nothing to do with a person's age."
A soldier named Xiang Mingjun wrote to the federation,
expressing his approval of the selection of the top 10 modern women, who
are attentive to their husbands, tender to their children, filial to their
aged parents and friendly to their neighbours.
In the house of another of the top 10 modern women,
Zhang Guiqing, general manager of Shenyang's Mulan Industrial Corporation,
colourful flowers can be found everywhere. Zhang was cleaning the house
when the reporter visited her.
"Despite her fame as a boss of 27 enterprises, she
is a good housekeeper and an attentive housewife. She is also a capable
and kind mother," Zhang's husband said proudly.
Zhang, 48, has six children, four of whom are now
university students. "The whole family is happy at my being
chosen," she said.
According to the director of the women' s federation,
two of the most important criteria for the top 10 modern women out of the
city's 2.63 million women are having been praised by authorities above the
city goverument level and having a harmonious and happy family.
This is quite a departure from past attitudes, in the
days when a strong sense of family was often regarded as selfish and
bourgeois, Zhang said.
Only two years ago, the story of a mo:lel woman teacher
who persevered in her work and ignored the pleas of her sick son was
widely cited with approval.
|